A senior applicant can describe the complexity of their work without telling an interview panel what a former client said. The distinction matters particularly when a firm already acts on the other side of a live dispute.
On 5 November 2026, Legal Futures reported a High Court decision allowing a firm to continue acting despite recruiting a partner who had previously supervised work for the opposing party. In Re A and C, the court examined what information the solicitor actually held and the evidence in the particular case. The decision is not general clearance for a firm to act whenever a new recruit says they do not remember a file.
Separate recruitment questions from file checks
At interview, ask about types of work, supervisory responsibility and the support the candidate expects. “What did you personally review?” is more useful than “What was the client’s negotiating position?” Describe the role without identifying a sensitive matter merely to see whether the applicant recognises it.
Agree who will handle any potential overlap privately. If a concern emerges, pause discussion of that matter and route it to the person responsible for conflicts at the firm. Do not circulate client details in interview notes or ask the recruitment consultant to resolve the issue.
Plan for the first day, not just the offer letter
Before allocating work or setting up access, establish who has assessed the overlap, what controls they have decided are necessary, and who must know about those controls. Include assistants, shared inboxes and team meetings in that discussion: restricting one folder may achieve little if the file is discussed in an open meeting.
For a Yorkshire practice hiring across offices, establish which teams actually share files and support staff. Different office addresses alone do not answer that question.
Sources: Legal Futures, 5 November 2026; High Court judgment, [2026] EWHC 2842 (Fam).